Are you in a healthy relationship with your subscribers?

The only way to have a friend is to be one.

— Ralph Waldo Emerson (an American lecturer, poet, and essayist)

This week feels like a good excuse to talk about relationships. Not the roses-and-chocolates kind (thank goodness), but the ones that form when someone whispers those magical words:

“Subscribe me to your newsletter.”

Chances are that neither of you are looking for a quick fling. You both hope there’s a relationship that lasts.

If marketing is about building relationships then we should be thinking about them in the same way: where is the trust? The respect? Where is the consistency, and care?

The most respected brands don’t behave like pickup artists. They don’t shout. They don’t try to “win” every interaction. They’re in it for the long-haul, not a one-night send.

Instead, they’re built on the same things that make any healthy relationship work.

How to lose a subscriber in 10 days

It’s a beautiful thing when a subscriber and a marketer meet for the first time. But it’s all too easy to ruin something that could blossom before you’ve even had a chance to get to know each other.

Respect

Respect is the obvious place to start.

Ethical email begins with a genuine opt-in — not a trick, not a checkbox buried in small print, not a vague promise. Just a clear invitation and a clear yes. Anything else might grow a list faster, but it’s a shaky foundation to build on.

Trust

Trust is built from many things, but from day one, it starts with your tone.

You can usually tell within a sentence whether an email was written with respect or desperation. Fear-based CTAs, manufactured urgency, and manipulative language might convert in the short term — but they quietly erode trust.

If you wouldn’t say it to someone you actually like, should it belong in anyone’s inbox?

Consistency

Consistency matters too, but not in the “never miss a day” sense.

In healthy relationships, consistency means showing up reliably when it counts. The same is true with email.

A thoughtful message sent slightly late is far better than a perfectly scheduled one sent with slop. People rarely expect perfection — they expect honesty.

Engagement

One of the easiest traps to fall into is confusing attention with affection.

High open rates, big spikes, viral moments — they can feel great, but they’re not the same as trust.

Trust is basically impossible to measure, but it shows up in replies, in people sticking around, in someone referencing an email you sent weeks ago because it actually meant something to them.

Care

Healthy relationships also leave space.

You don’t need to be in someone’s inbox constantly to stay relevant. In fact, restraint is often a sign of confidence. Sending fewer, better emails shows respect for your reader’s time. That respect is often felt, whether you know it or not.

When email marketing goes wrong, it often looks like insecurity: over-sending, over-optimising, chasing validation through metrics that don’t tell the full story.

When it goes right, it feels calm. Intentional. Sustainable, even.

At its best, email marketing, like all good relationships, isn’t a short-term game. It’s a relationship you build over time. You earn over time. Built on clarity, care, trust, and a long-term mindset.

Pop the question

So this Valentine’s Day, it might be worth asking:

Would you want to be on your list?

Happy Valentine’s Day 💚

If you enjoyed this, please spread the love.